Ed Miliband

1
Image
Hi all,
Before starting a UK election topic in the mundane would anyone care to discuss chart of Labour leader Ed Miliband? He has angular Mercury and Moon but how would others see Saturn and Jupiter.?Family would be interesting too. Both Ed and his brother were contenders for the party leadership so he defeated his own brother. They both follow their father in being secular Jewish socialists but Miliband pere was more an intellectual and writer
Matthew

PS it is Rodden rated B in ADB
Last edited by Mjacob on Wed Feb 11, 2015 4:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Matthew Goulding

2
Sorry but I find this chart in particular incomplete without the outer planets. Chiron in 2 degrees Aries is exactly square to his Sun. And the other outer planets are particularly relevant in this chart.

E

3
Sorry Fleur but this is the Traditional forum so outer planets are not relevant. There is a precedent for posting the same chart in two different forums though
Matthew
Matthew Goulding

4
Mjacob wrote:
Before starting a UK election topic in the mundane would anyone care to discuss chart of Labour leader Ed Miliband? He has angular Mercury and Moon but how would others see Saturn and Jupiter.?Family would be interesting too. Both Ed and his brother were contenders for the party leadership so he defeated his own brother. They both follow their father in being secular Jewish socialists but Miliband pere was more an intellectual and writer
Matthew

PS it is Rodden rated B in ADB
Hi Mjacob

I was planning to start a thread on the mundane forum this week looking at the UK General on May 7th.

That will include analysis of Ed Miliband and David Cameron's charts.

I'm not really clear what is especially traditional about this topic.

If you want to focus on a particular nativity I would have thought the General + Nativity forum would be more appropriate

Mark.
As thou conversest with the heavens, so instruct and inform thy minde according to the image of Divinity William Lilly

5
I would be happy to follow your forthcoming posts in that case. Unlike the subject of this I do not wish to argue but traditional natal astrology is both traditional and natal I reckon
Matthew
Matthew Goulding

6
I think the mundane forum would be the perfect place to develop this further - suits the political theme of the subject and keeps it open for anyone to contribute. Unless there is some specific feature of the chart that you want to consider from a traditional approach Matthew? If there is, you could always raise that particular point in this thread, so that responses are focussed on the use of traditional/historical natal techniques.